#1INDIAN POLITY & JUDICIARY
Top ↑Supreme Court on Constitutional Validity of Execution by Hanging
ЁЯФ╣ Why in News & Constitutional Examination
The Supreme Court of India evaluated the constitutional validity of execution by hanging under Section 354(5) of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC), 1973, examining whether the method violates Article 21 rights ensuring human dignity.
ЁЯФ╣ Judicial Precedents & Legal Arguments
The Apex Court referred to the landmark Deena v. Union of India (1983) judgment which upheld hanging as quick and humane when compared to lethal injection or electrocution, observing the absence of definitive empirical proof showing alternative methods cause less suffering.
ЁЯФ╣ Law Commission Recommendations
The 187th Law Commission Report (2003) recommended amending Section 354(5) to provide convicts an option between lethal injection and hanging. The Union Government highlighted that lethal injections carry risks of vein collapse and prolonged agony.
ЁЯФ╣ UP PCS / STATE PCS HIGH-YIELD VALUE ADDITION
тАвтАв Constitutional Provisions: Article 21 (Right to Life & Dignity) & Article 72/161 (Pardoning Powers of President and Governor).
тАвтАв Key Precedents: Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980) ('Rarest of rare case' doctrine); Machi Singh (1983); Shatrughan Chauhan (2014) (undue delay in mercy plea as ground for commutation).
тАвтАв UP PCS Prelims Focus: CrPC Sec 354(5), Mercy petition procedures, Law Commission reports.